Every competitive sports game has that one moment where you stop, stare at the screen, and think: How is this even possible? In MLB The Show 25, that moment often comes when you pull up the stats of the number-one-ranked player in the world. A record of 350–58. A .435 batting average. An ERA sitting comfortably around 5.8 in a hyper-competitive online environment where even elite players struggle to stay consistent.

These aren’t just good numbers. They’re absurd. And naturally, the next question follows: What does his team look like?

Welcome to the world of the God Squad—a meticulously crafted lineup built to dominate every matchup, MLB The Show 25 Stubs, and leave no weaknesses for opponents to attack. After piecing together box scores from multiple games, one thing becomes immediately clear: this team isn’t just stacked with talent—it’s strategically designed around one core philosophy.

Switch-hitting supremacy.

The Philosophy Behind the #1 Ranked Squad

At the highest level of MLB The Show 25, raw stick skills alone are no longer enough. Everyone can hit. Everyone knows how to pitch mix. What separates the absolute best is roster construction—how well your lineup adapts to different pitchers, stadiums, and late-game situations.

The number one player’s squad leans heavily into switch hitters, and for good reason. Switch-hitters eliminate platoon disadvantages, forcing opponents into uncomfortable pitching decisions every single at-bat. No matter whether a lefty or righty comes out of the bullpen, the hitter always retains the handedness advantage.

This lineup isn’t just strong—it’s oppressive.

Breaking Down the God Squad Lineup

After reviewing multiple box scores and appearances, the core roster becomes clear. This is not a team thrown together randomly. Every name serves a purpose.

Jasson Domínguez

Domínguez is a staple in elite lineups, and for good reason. He combines elite switch-hitting power, strong contact, and athletic defense. His swing is smooth from both sides of the plate, and he thrives against velocity—something that dominates higher difficulty levels.

In MLB The Show 25, Domínguez excels at turning mistakes into no-doubt home runs, especially in hitter-friendly parks. As a switch-hitter, he’s never neutralized by matchup-based pitching.

Cal Raleigh

Catcher is often a weak spot for many teams, but Raleigh flips that narrative entirely. A powerful switch-hitter behind the plate is a massive advantage, especially when opponents expect defensive-focused catchers.

Raleigh punishes fastballs up in the zone and provides real power from both sides, making him dangerous even in late innings when bullpens get involved.

José Ramírez

Few cards are as consistently dominant as José Ramírez. He’s the prototype of what makes switch-hitters elite in MLB The Show 25: speed, power, contact, and reaction time.

Ramírez is especially deadly against breaking balls. His ability to sit back and still drive off-speed pitches makes him a nightmare against players who rely too heavily on sliders and curveballs.

Francisco Lindor

Lindor anchors the infield with elite defense and elite bat control. In competitive play, defense matters far more than most players realize, and Lindor provides flawless reliability at shortstop.

Offensively, Lindor’s switch-hitting ability allows him to stay aggressive in any count. He excels at turning borderline pitches into line drives—perfect for extending rallies and keeping pressure on opponents.

Ian Happ

Happ is often overlooked by casual players, but elite competitors understand his value. His balanced attributes and switch-hitting ability make him an ideal mid-lineup presence.

Happ thrives in clutch situations, especially against bullpen arms where pitch confidence begins to falter. He doesn’t need perfect PCI placement to do damage, which is invaluable at high difficulty.

Kyle Schwarber (“Schwarbby”)

Power. Pure, unfiltered power.

Schwarber is one of the most feared bats in MLB The Show 25, and his switch-hitting card elevates him even further. Mistakes against Schwarber don’t just leave the yard—they leave the stadium.

While his defense isn’t elite, his offensive output more than compensates. Schwarber changes how opponents pitch entire lineups because they’re terrified of falling behind in counts.

Mickey Mantle

Mantle remains one of the most iconic and overpowered cards in the game’s history, and MLB The Show 25 is no exception. Elite contact, elite power, elite speed, elite defense—and of course, switch-hitting.

Mantle is the kind of card that can carry games by himself. He’s just as dangerous leading off as he is batting cleanup, and his presence forces pitchers into conservative patterns that can be exploited by the rest of the lineup.

Carlos Beltrán

Beltrán adds veteran consistency and sneaky pop. His swing is compact and forgiving, making him ideal for tough at-bats against elite pitching.

As a switch-hitter, Beltrán excels at driving pitches to the gaps, turning singles into doubles and doubles into rally starters.

Ketel Marte

Marte’s versatility makes him invaluable. He can play multiple positions while maintaining strong offensive output from both sides of the plate.

In MLB The Show 25, Marte shines against high-velocity pitchers, where his quick swing path allows him to keep up with outlier fastballs.

Carlos Santana

Santana rounds out the switch-hitting parade with patience and discipline. He thrives in deep counts and punishes pitchers who miss their spots late.

Santana’s ability to draw walks also adds an underrated element: pitch count pressure. Forcing starters out early is a massive advantage in competitive modes.

Pitching: The Silent Backbone

While the provided content focuses primarily on the lineup, glimpses of pitching stats and box scores suggest a rotation built around control and deception, rather than raw velocity alone.

At the highest level, pitchers succeed by:

Mixing speeds effectively

Tunneling pitches

Exploiting opponent tendencies

The number one player doesn’t rely on gimmicks. Instead, he forces hitters into weak contact, trusting his defense and lineup to outscore opponents consistently.

Why Switch-Hitters Dominate MLB The Show 25

The meta in MLB The Show 25 heavily favors switch-hitters for several reasons:

No Platoon Weaknesses

You’re never forced into unfavorable matchups.

Bullpen Neutralization

Late-game specialist pitchers lose their edge.

PCI Consistency

Many switch-hitters have forgiving swing animations that reward solid timing.

Psychological Pressure

Opponents feel like they can’t escape damage, no matter who they bring in.

When nearly an entire lineup consists of switch-hitters, every inning becomes a grind for the opposing player.

Lessons for Aspiring Competitive Players

You don’t need the exact same roster to improve—but you can learn from the philosophy behind it.

Prioritize switch-hitters when possible

Build lineups that stay dangerous late into games

Value consistency over flashy stats

Defense matters more than you think

The number one player isn’t number one by accident. His team reflects a deep understanding of how MLB The Show 25 actually plays at the highest level.

Final Thoughts

Looking at this God Squad, one thing is undeniable: this team is better than most—and it’s built that way on purpose. It may feel uncomfortable to run this many switch-hitters if you’re not used to it, but the results speak for themselves buy MLB The Show 25 Stubs.

A 350–58 record doesn’t lie.

If you’re serious about climbing the ranked ladder in MLB The Show 25, studying teams like this isn’t optional—it’s essential. The meta evolves, mechanics shift, and patches come and go, but smart roster construction will always remain the foundation of greatness.

And if being the best means embracing an army of switch-hitters?

Well… there’s a reason the number one player in the world does exactly that.