One of the most exciting aspects of MLB The Show 25 is the ability to shape your own baseball career through Road to the Show (RTTS). This single-player journey lets you create a custom ballplayer and guide them from the draft through the minor leagues and into the majors. Along the way, you'll make important decisions that shape not just your skills, but also your role on the team.

 

But what happens if you realize the position you chose at the start doesn't suit your playstyle? Maybe playing shortstop isn't as fun as you thought, or perhaps you'd rather be on the mound than in the outfield. Fortunately, MLB The Show 25 offers ways to change your position in RTTS, though the process isn't as straightforward as simply editing your player profile. This guide explains how and when you can change positions, what limitations exist, and how smart use of resources like MLB 25 Stubs can make the transition smoother.

 

Choosing Your Starting Role

 

When you first create a new ballplayer in RTTS, the game asks whether you want to be a pitcher, a position player, or a two-way player. This initial choice determines how your early career unfolds. If you pick pitcher, you'll be limited to the mound, while position players cover all non-pitching roles. Two-way players combine both, letting you hit and pitch until you eventually specialize.

 

This first decision is crucial because you can't instantly edit it later. For instance, you can't start as a catcher and simply flip a setting to become a right fielder. Position changes require in-game conversations and progression events, which means you'll need to be patient and intentional about the path you take.

 

Early Opportunity to Shift Focus

 

The first real chance to alter your role comes immediately after the draft. If you entered RTTS as a two-way player, reporters will ask whether you plan to stick with that path at the major-league level. If you respond with, "I'll need to evaluate that," you'll unlock a branching opportunity a few weeks later.

 

After a handful of games, usually in late April, your manager will call you in for a conversation. At that point, you'll be offered the chance to transition into a pure pitcher or pure position player. The catch, however, is that this decision doesn't allow you to change which position you're playing, it only locks you into pitching or fielding full-time.

 

Talking to Your Agent

 

The most common way to change your specific position in MLB The Show 25 comes through conversations with your agent. If you're unhappy with where you're playing, say you're stuck at third base but really want to patrol the outfield, you'll eventually get a phone call where your agent asks how things are going.

 

During this dialogue, you can express dissatisfaction with your current position. If you push for a change, your agent will escalate the request to your team's manager. After some back-and-forth, the manager may agree to move you to a new position.

 

The tricky part is that you can't initiate these calls. You have to wait for your agent to reach out, and the timing is highly unpredictable. Some players report getting the opportunity after just a few weeks, while others grind through entire seasons without ever receiving the call. One factor seems to be how much you're actually playing. Simulating games often delays these conversations, while consistently playing your matchups can make the call more likely.

 

When a Position Change Becomes Unlikely

 

As your RTTS career progresses, the odds of successfully changing positions diminish. If you're already deep into a major league career, your organization may be less willing to experiment with shifting you around the diamond. By then, your stats and attributes are usually tailored to your current role, making a transition even harder.

 

For example, if you've invested heavily in defensive upgrades for second base, those same boosts won't fully transfer if you switch to catcher. Likewise, pitchers who've spent tokens and resources improving velocity and control may find those investments wasted if they suddenly move to shortstop.

 

This is where managing resources like MLB The Show 25 Stubs becomes critical. Stubs can be used to purchase equipment and perks that supplement your attributes. If you're considering a switch, investing your MLB 25 Stubs in flexible gear, such as batting gloves or cleats that improve multiple stats, gives you more freedom. That way, you won't feel locked into one position because of highly specialized upgrades.

 

Starting Fresh as a Last Resort

 

Sometimes, the best solution isn't to force a position change but to start over. If you're early in your RTTS career and realize you chose the wrong role, restarting might save time and frustration. Creating a new ballplayer lets you pick the exact position you want without waiting for random in-game events to line up.

 

While it can be tough to abandon a save you've already sunk hours into, starting fresh ensures you don't waste attribute points and tokens on a path you no longer enjoy. And with smart use of MLB The Show 25 Stubs, you can accelerate your new journey. For example, buying training packs, equipment, or perks can help a newly created ballplayer reach competitive levels much faster than grinding alone.

 

Final Thoughts

 

Changing positions in MLB The Show 25 isn't as simple as flipping a switch, but it is possible if you know where to look. Whether through early post-draft conversations, discussions with your agent, or a complete restart, you do have options. The key is balancing patience with smart resource management.

 

If you're willing to wait for your agent's call and keep grinding through games, you may get the chance to shift naturally. If not, restarting with a new ballplayer ensures you'll enjoy RTTS exactly the way you want. And throughout the process, remember that smart use of MLB The Show 25 Stubs can make any transition, whether it's to a new position or a new career, much smoother.

 

In the end, the flexibility of Road to the Show ensures that your career is truly your own. Whether you stick with your original position or forge a new path, MLB The Show 25 gives you the tools to create the baseball story you've always imagined.